If you don't lower it, either will fit.
My 16x8" ET11 wheels are close at the front with 40mm lowering and camber mod, and would require the arches to be rolled on the back to not rub, so a wheel 6mm wider on the outside and pushed 5mm further out as well will hit like mad. ET16 is the way to go.
__________________
MY97 940 CD LPT Super Sports Edition 2 Turbo, Midnight Purple, 175,000 miles.