Thread: V50 G/box : - Oscillating RPM When Driving
View Single Post
Old Nov 9th, 2019, 22:03   #5
lockstock
Senior Member
 

Last Online: Jan 15th, 2024 15:32
Join Date: Jul 2019
Location: london
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by eric19371 View Post
Update: I ran it with a diagnostics tool connected and once it had warmed up it kept flipping between "Slipping lock up" and "Fix lock up" every now and again on a fairly flat surface at a constant speed. Yes, when it was in 'geartronic' it seemed ok. The gearbox doesn't seem to be noticeably slipping otherwise.

I also looked through the receipts I got with the car. They were all mostly main dealer up until two years ago (it was very well looked after) and there was no mention of the transmission fluid being changed or topped up (this was listed on the dealer check list as 'n/a'). I can therefore assume that it has never been changed.

I have been quoted £200 by my local reputable garage to change the transmission oil, of which half the cost is the oil and the rest being labour. I have seen second hand gearboxes on eBay for £500 (condition questionable?), and £1,800 +vat for a new gearbox.

This car has been otherwise reliable and apart from £400 for new front shocks hasn't cost me much in maintenance (it did also cost £300 for three new tyres and £250 for a spare key). I only bought it in March this year for £1,800 but what with all this and my last car being destroyed by an engine fire at the start of the year* I am wondering if I am cursed and I should just put it on eBay for £800 and go and get myself a pedal bike...

* https://www.kentonline.co.uk/maidsto...r-park-199942/
if it were me, I would live with it, keep it in geartronic mode and spend no more on it. Id probs not even change gear oil. I'd then try to eek 2 years out of the car, putting as little money in as possible and save for a replacement when the gearbox gives up, could be a long way down the road.
lockstock is offline   Reply With Quote
The Following User Says Thank You to lockstock For This Useful Post: