Quote:
Originally Posted by MacV50
Hi folks
Currently driving a V50 but desperately need more space due to 3 kids and a dog (acquired an extra kid and dog a couple of years ago  )
So, we've had a look around and although we don't need 7 seats, the Disco 4 does fit the bill. Really don't like the X5 or 1st gen XC90; Touareg is too small inside and will never EVER drive an MPV
So, we're pretty much set on a Disco 4 but LR reliability is a worry and the new XC90 is rather nice. Just wondered if anyone has had both and could offer a real-world comparison
Thanks in advance |
Servicing is about 3 times the cost for the Disco in our area. Mpg is about 25 for the Disco and 40 for the XC90 assuming both have the diesel engine. The XC90 is quieter. The Disco is better for extreme off road but the XC90 is surprisingly capable off road but does not have so much wheel articulation as the Disco. The XC90 is in a class of it's own as far as the interior goes. Makes the Disco look like it came out of the ark. Occasionaly the Disco needs it's body removed to service some parts and everything on the XC90 can be serviced normally. The Disco is more reliable than it used to be but be prepared for some big bills out of warranty.
Seven seats are great if you have 3 kids because they will start to argue at some point and it can really diffuse the tension if one can go in a different row. Leaves room for a friend as well. But the both have 7 seats anyway. The XC90 is much bigger inside than the Disco though. Even the old XC90 was bigger inside than the Disco and the new XC90 is a lot bigger than the old one inside.
Hope that helps. Personally I like the Disco but prefer the XC90 for an everyday car.